Jeffrey B. Rubin’s presentation “Sources of Hope in a Runaway World” offered a searching meditation on how authentic hope might be sustained in an era marked by fear, demoralization, and widening social division. Rather than reassuring his audience with optimistic predictions, Rubin began from a more unsettling premise: that things may be worse than we believe — and that, paradoxically, there may also be more hope than we know. This tension framed his inquiry into where realistic, durable hope can be found.

Rubin distinguished genuine hope from what he described as brittle or sentimental optimism — a defensive insistence that everything will turn out well regardless of evidence. Such optimism, he suggested, often functions as protection against grief and mourning. By contrast, authentic hope requires the capacity to face despair without being consumed by it. Drawing on decades of psychoanalytic work with individuals who have had to “go through hell before seeing the light,” Rubin grounded his reflections in clinical experience as well as historical perspective.

He situated contemporary despair within a longer cultural arc, referencing analyses of American history that trace shifting sources of meaning — from God, to nation, to the self. When the self becomes the primary site of allegiance, Rubin argued, it proves an unstable foundation for meaning, often producing alienation and melancholy rather than fulfillment. This psychohistorical backdrop framed his search for alternative sources of hope that do not depend on denial or ideological certainty.

The first such source Rubin identified was the power of discontent. While dissatisfaction can demoralize, it can also mobilize. Drawing on observations of global grassroots movements, he noted how countless ordinary citizens, largely outside the spotlight of mainstream media, are engaged in efforts to protect ecosystems, challenge injustice, and foster community resilience. Discontent, when coupled with imagination and action, can become a generative force rather than a paralyzing one.

A second source of hope lies in the human capacity to awaken from self-deception. Psychoanalysis teaches that self-deception is ubiquitous, yet it also demonstrates the remarkable ability of individuals to recognize and relinquish illusions that impoverish their lives. Rubin emphasized that people often pursue what does not truly nourish them — wealth, power, consumption — at great cost to relationships and well-being. The possibility of awakening to these costs, however fragile, represents a powerful opening for change.

Rubin then turned to positive contagion, a phenomenon less studied than its destructive counterpart. While fear and hatred spread rapidly, so too can courage, generosity, and ethical commitment. When individuals resist dehumanizing values and live differently, they may inspire others, creating pockets of moral energy that counteract despair. Such contagion does not require mass movements; it often begins in small, local acts of integrity and care.

The utopian imagination formed a more ambivalent yet essential source of hope. Rubin acknowledged that utopian projects have repeatedly produced catastrophe, from totalitarian regimes to coercive communal experiments. Yet he resisted the conclusion that utopian thinking should be abandoned altogether. Utopias, he argued, express aspirations that expand the horizons of what seems possible. Even when unrealizable, they challenge the assumption that existing social arrangements are inevitable or eternal. Without such imaginative provocations, societies risk surrendering too easily to the status quo.

Rubin gave concrete form to this idea through his discussion of dream work, particularly the experiential dream-group method developed by Montague Ullman. Ullman’s approach, which treats dreams as shared human creations rather than expert property, exemplifies a small-scale utopian practice. In these groups, hierarchy recedes, criticism gives way to curiosity, and participants collaborate in exploring meaning. Rubin described such groups as fostering safety, openness, and mutual transformation — offering an “intimation of utopia” grounded in lived experience rather than ideology.

Another wellspring of hope emerged in Rubin’s concept of inner space — the capacity to reflect, imagine, and feel independently of external pressures. Inner space allows individuals to resist the hypnotic pull of prevailing narratives and to envision alternatives. It supports empathy across differences and opens the possibility of creative responses to entrenched conflicts. Cultivating inner space, Rubin suggested, is not withdrawal from the world but preparation for wiser engagement with it.

The final and most powerful source of hope Rubin identified was love. Love, in its many forms, operates beyond political manipulation and resists total control. Drawing on psychoanalytic trauma theory, he described trauma as an unbearable affect without a relational home. When ordinary assumptions about safety and continuity are shattered — whether through personal catastrophe or collective upheaval — love expressed through witnessing, attunement, and solidarity can provide that missing home. Such relational presence does not erase suffering but makes it bearable, enabling resilience and healing.

The discussion following Rubin’s presentation deepened these themes. Participants reflected on how ordinary routines and relationships sustain meaning during extreme historical trauma, how shared rituals can rapidly restore collective morale, and how dialogue across ideological divides requires curiosity about the emotional logic underlying opposing positions. Rather than pathologizing difference, Rubin advocated for a stance of listening that suspends judgment long enough for genuine encounter to occur — a posture familiar to psychoanalytic practice but urgently needed in civic life.

Taken together, Rubin’s presentation and the ensuing discussion offered a psychohistorical vision of hope as neither naive optimism nor passive endurance. Hope, in this account, emerges from engagement with suffering, from imagination disciplined by realism, and from sustained commitment to human connection. In a world that often feels unmoored and accelerated beyond control, these sources of hope do not promise easy solutions. They do, however, remind us that the capacities for renewal — ethical, psychological, and relational — remain deeply human and historically consequential.

About the Author:

Inna Rozentsvit, MD, PhD, MBA, MSciEd, is a neurologist, neurorehabilitation and neurodiversity specialist, psychoanalytically trained clinician, educator, and editor. She is the founder of Neurorecovery Solutions and the developer of Functional PsychoNeuroBiology®, an integrative framework examining relationships among brain, mind, body, and psychological experience, with particular attention to neuroplasticity, trauma, and human development.

She serves as Programs Director of the Object Relations Institute, Editor-in-Chief of ORI Academic Press and MindConsiliums, Associate Editor of Clio’s Psyche, and Associate Director of the Psychohistory Forum. Her interdisciplinary work encompasses neuropsychoanalysis, psychohistory, psychobiography, and the psychological dimensions of aging and adaptation.

How to Cite This:

Rozentsvit, I. (2025). Sources of hope in a runaway world: Psychoanalytic perspectives on resilience and transformation (based on a presentation by Jeffrey B. Rubin at the 48th Annual Conference of the IPhA). Psychohistory News, 44(3/4), 3.

PDF downloads:
Download this Article PDF
Download full Issue PDF



Editorial Disclaimer: The views and interpretations expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the position of Psychohistory News or the International Psychohistorical Association. For comments, please contact the author directly or submit a response to our Letters to the Editor section.
keyboard_arrow_up