The articles presented in this issue under Perspectives and Positions reflect sincere, divergent attempts to grapple with one of the most emotionally charged and morally destabilizing conflicts of our time. The International Psychohistorical Association has long upheld the value of open inquiry, pluralism, and the examination of contested narratives. At the same time, psychohistory carries a responsibility not only to host perspectives, but to examine how historical facts, psychological processes, and moral reasoning become distorted under conditions of collective trauma.

This editorial response is offered in that spirit.

October 7, 2023, marked the largest mass killing of Jewish civilians since the Holocaust. Over 1,200 Israelis — primarily civilians — were murdered in a single day through coordinated attacks involving torture, rape, mutilation, burning, and kidnapping. These acts were not incidental to military engagement; they were the explicit objective. Documented footage — much of it recorded by the perpetrators themselves — confirms the intentional targeting of civilians, including women, children, and the elderly.

The attacks themselves were marked by sexualized violence, mutilation, and ritualized cruelty, accompanied by public celebration and extensive documentation by perpetrators and civilian participants alike. The filming and dissemination of these acts transformed violence into performance, signaling not only an intent to kill but to humiliate, terrorize, and symbolically dominate. Such practices reflect a regression to pre-modern modes of violence in which cruelty becomes communicative, identity-affirming, and morally inverted.

A defining feature of the October 7 attacks was the mass abduction of civilians. Hostage-taking extended the violence beyond the initial assault, transforming it into a prolonged psychological weapon. Many captives were held for weeks or months under conditions of deprivation, without access to medical care or international humanitarian oversight. This sustained captivity compounded the original trauma and produced an enduring moral injury for families, communities, and the wider public.

From a psychohistorical perspective, the combination of mass murder, prolonged captivity, and ritualized cruelty constitutes a collective trauma of existential magnitude, not only for Israelis, but for Jews globally. When measured proportionally to population size, Israel’s civilian losses on October 7 exceed by more than tenfold the per-capita civilian loss experienced by the United States on September 11, 2001. This proportional reality matters, not as a competition of suffering, but as a grounding point for moral reasoning.

Violence, Proportion, and the Misuse of the Genocide Frame

The term genocide carries a precise legal and historical meaning. It refers to the intentional destruction of a people as such. In psychohistorical discourse, however, the term is often stripped of its specificity and repurposed as a symbolic weapon—used to express outrage, moral disgust, or political identification rather than historical accuracy.

Israel’s military response to October 7 must be evaluated within the framework of asymmetric warfare, in which a state actor confronts a non-state organization that embeds military infrastructure within civilian populations, including schools, hospitals, and religious institutions. Civilian casualties in such contexts are tragic and morally consequential, but they are not, by definition, evidence of genocidal intent.

The distinction between war crimes, moral injury, and genocide is not semantic hair-splitting. Collapsing these categories undermines the capacity for ethical judgment and fuels moral absolutism — an all-or-nothing stance that forecloses reflection, nuance, and historical responsibility.

Selective Empathy and Moral Splitting

One of the most striking psychohistorical phenomena following October 7 has been the emergence of selective empathy — the capacity to mourn one population while erasing or minimizing the suffering of another. In many public and academic spaces, outrage over Palestinian civilian deaths was immediate and absolute, while acknowledgment of Israeli trauma was delayed, conditional, or absent altogether.

This pattern reflects a classic mechanism of moral splitting, in which one group is assigned the role of absolute victim and another the role of absolute perpetrator. Such splitting is not evidence of moral clarity, but of psychological defense under conditions of overwhelming affect.

From a psychohistorical standpoint, selective empathy often signals the intrusion of ideological identification over attachment-based ethics. When political identity supersedes relational reality, compassion becomes conditional, and moral reasoning collapses into slogan and symbol.

Historical Amnesia and the Nakba Narrative

Several contributions in this section reference the Nakba as a foundational trauma comparable to genocide. This framing requires clarification. The events surrounding the 1948 Arab–Israeli war involved displacement and suffering, but they occurred within the context of a regional war initiated by neighboring Arab states following the United Nations partition plan—one accepted by Jewish leadership and rejected by Arab leadership.

The Nakba narrative has since evolved into a mythic structure of eternal victimhood, often detached from historical causality, internal political decisions, and parallel population displacements throughout the Middle East during the same period. To equate Nakba with genocide is not only historically inaccurate; it constitutes a psychohistorical distortion that transforms political defeat into sacred trauma and assigns inherited guilt across generations.

Such narratives function psychologically to externalize responsibility and to sanctify grievance, foreclosing paths toward reconciliation.

Moral Injury and the Aftermath of October 7

Moral injury arises when individuals or groups experience a rupture between their ethical expectations and lived reality. For Israelis and Jews worldwide, October 7 shattered the assumption that historical memory of Jewish vulnerability would protect against its repetition—or at minimum, against its denial.

The rapid inversion of victim and perpetrator narratives following the attacks has compounded this injury. Accusations of genocide levied within days—before Israel had launched a full military response — suggest that moral conclusions were pre-formed, awaiting only a triggering event.

From a psychohistorical perspective, such reactions reflect preexisting fantasy structures rather than evidence-based analysis. They reveal how deeply entrenched symbolic frameworks can override empirical reality when ideological commitments are threatened.

Toward Psychohistorical Responsibility

Psychohistory does not ask for unanimity. It asks for honesty, proportion, and psychological insight. It asks that we distinguish between grief and accusation, between outrage and analysis, between solidarity and moral erasure.

The articles in this section contribute to an important conversation. This editorial response seeks not to silence them, but to situate them within a psychohistorical framework that resists simplification, honors historical specificity, and recognizes the psychological costs of moral collapse.

In moments of collective trauma, the task of psychohistory is not to choose sides—but to illuminate how sides are chosen, why empathy narrows, and how moral reasoning becomes distorted under the pressure of fear, loss, and inherited narratives.

Only through such inquiry can psychohistory remain faithful to its foundational aim: understanding the emotional forces that shape history, rather than reenacting them.

References:

United Nations. (2024). Report on conflict-related sexual violence committed during the October 7, 2023, attacks and against hostages held in Gaza. United Nations.

Troy, G. (2024). The Essential Guide to October 7th and Its Aftermath: facts, Figures, History. The Jewish People Policy Institute.

Jewish Policy Center. (2024). Israeli genocide? The world is wrong — again.

The Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs. (2024). Debunking the Nakba narrative: Historical truth, modern politics, and the path to peace.

Hassan Yousef, M. (2023–2025). Son of Hamas: Public testimony and interviews on Hamas ideology and the October 7 attacks.

Pinker, S. (2011). The better angels of our nature: Why violence has declined. Viking.

Dershowitz, A. (2023). The case for Israel. Wiley.

About the Author:

Inna Rozentsvit, MD, PhD, MBA, MSciEd, is a neurologist and neurorehabilitation specialist trained in psychoanalysis. She is a founder and neuropsychoeducator at the non-profit organization NeurorecoverySolutions, Inc., a programs director at the Object Relations Institute for Psychotherapy and Psychoanalysis, and editor-in-chief of the ORI Academic Press, MindMend Publishing Co., and MindConsiliums, the interdisciplinary journal.
She may be contacted at or www.innarozentsvit.com. 

How to Cite This:

Rozentsvit, I. (2025). Editorial response: Psychohistorical clarifications on violence, proportion, and moral injury after October 7. Psychohistory News, 44(3/4), 17.

PDF downloads:
Download this Article PDF
Download full Issue PDF



Editorial Disclaimer: The views and interpretations expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the position of Psychohistory News or the International Psychohistorical Association. For comments, please contact the author directly or submit a response to our Letters to the Editor section.
keyboard_arrow_up