My strong impression is that millions of White, Black, Hispanic, and other men are feeling ignored and belittled by the enormous societal and especially Democratic Party focus on women breaking through glass ceilings.  In the past, boys and men have been treated like they were more important than women, even though girls develop faster than boys, graduate more readily from college, and previously overwhelmingly accepted their place in society as secondary to men.    

Traditionally, mothers were there to give birth to boys, nurture them, and encourage them, in most cases, to greater public success than their daughters!  However, now, society is beginning to think about male dominance as being unfair and part of the system that worked to keep women pregnant and “down on the farm.” Working-class and other men feel passed over and not compensated emotionally.  The results are higher rates of male drug addiction, suicide, and right-wing radicalization.   

To millions of men who felt hurt, it was exhilarating to see Hulk Hogan as the epitome of a macho male at the Republican National Convention, even if many intellectually laughed it off.  Male dominance is something that Trump is totally at home in, as expressed in his bragging to Billy Bush that you can get away with grabbing women sexually in their genitalia.  Regrettably, even after this sexual abuse was exposed, Trump was still elected in 2016 and is now our 2025 president-elect.  

President Joe Biden and the Democrats have worked very hard in the last four years to improve the economic status and generally do good things for White, Black, and other working-class males. But in 2024, they did not run on this emotional platform, unlike their chauvinist Republican rival.  We, as psychohistorians, have long been speaking about fantasy being so powerful. I have argued for quite a while that fantasy is not only shaping but also replacing reality in so many Americans’ minds.   

The Biden-Harris programs supporting non-college-educated males made Democrats feel good, but Harris did not focus on this accomplishment which certainly was not an easy sell. Trump was so much more successful in appealing emotionally to working men. Based on more male than female support, Trump’s push for an authoritarian presidency, favorable to billionaires like Elon Musk, has succeeded. He is expected to seek to implement much of Project 2025 and stock the government with adherents to his cult of personality. As an overextending businessman, Trump was well-known for sometimes not paying his workers and builders, who assumed a billionaire (which Donald claimed at points even when he was insolvent) would be paying them. 

This brings us to the issue of some of the bases of misogyny. In my mind, counter-dependency ranks high on the list with an extremely large number of men. We are, as Shakespeare said, “women born,” weak and dependent on a woman in our early formative years. To males trying to prove their masculinity, dependency is seen as being babyish, which is the last thing so many boys and men are willing to acknowledge they want—although unconsciously, they are inclined to crave it.  Furthermore, in families where the father denigrates women and their individuality, boys are commonly trained to look down on women as they prove their masculinity.  Men raised in this manner tend to see women as the Madonna or the whore.  While mothers are idealized and protected, their individualism and femininity are not respected.   

Sibling rivalry often involves brothers and sisters, especially when sisters develop earlier than brothers and haven’t yet been taught to take a back seat to a man. As a scholar/therapist who has learned a lot about sibling rivalry in families, I’m wondering to what extent we now have sibling rivalry with mostly non-college-educated males of all races and backgrounds who are finding Trump more acceptable, even as he threatens to deport some of them. He also certainly will not have special programs for the Black and Hispanic working class, whatever his mostly worthless electoral promises may be.   

Not long before the election, archconservative Tucker Carlson, speaking at a rally, likened Donald Trump to “Daddy” and described him coming home angrily to give a “bad little girl” (Kamala is implied) a “vigorous spanking” (Right Side Broadcasting Network, 2024). Then, he launched an attack on Democrats as permissive parents. The way the crowd reacted lovingly to the “Daddy” spanking a woman captured the feelings of so many MAGA supporters. The MAGA women in these rallies remind me of Phyllis Schlafly, who so effectively fought against the Equal Rights Amendment in the name of women having a special, protected place in society.  While Schlafly felt empowered, leaving her six kids in the care of others to fight for traditional gender relations so effectively, she clearly set back women’s causes. Of course, Trump’s female supporters have many different motivations, including party loyalty, single-issue voting (e.g., anti-abortion), economic anxiety, White fear of being displaced, identification with their man’s political views, who they were voting against, and confusion due to the endless negative advertising. In addition, for many, Trump rallies are fun! 

Let me give two examples of misogyny.  When I was in the U.S. Army, a very nice Italian American soldier was quite eager to marry his Puerto Rican girlfriend. When I asked what made her special, he said, “Because I never got in her pants!”  Clearly, in his mind, she was suitable to become the mother of his children. A long-dead close friend of the family also comes to mind (I’ve changed all the names involved). Peter was a nine-year-old German Jew who escaped after Kristallnacht (“The Night of Broken Glass” when Hitler made it clear that Jews could only survive in Germany at the risk of their own lives) with his parents and sister. His story of extremely hard and intelligent work leading to success is admirable.  His father, Isaac, went from being a banker to becoming a laborer in a lumber yard who quickly learned English.  Meanwhile, Peter worked part-time starting at the age of nine while attending school and getting a good education. 

When Peter graduated from engineering college, Isaac’s accented English was quite good.  Isaac had a managerial job at the lumber yard and had saved enough money to start a business.  Father and son bought a broken-down one-truck lumber yard on the outskirts of Bridgeport, Connecticut, and turned it into a company that would make them multimillionaires. From firsthand experience of being a driver’s helper, loading trucks, and unloading freight cars there in the summers, I can speak about just how hard and intelligently these immigrants worked while creating numerous jobs for native-born Americans. Amidst much grumbling, they even broke the racial barrier by hiring a Black worker.  

Caroline, a very sweet and sheltered neighbor I had grown up with who was also a close friend of my older sister, married Peter, who was almost a decade her senior, partly because that’s what women were expected to do.  Her family, with some misgivings, encouraged the match, because they feared the alternative for her would have been to care for her cancer-ridden mother (An aunt had done this and become a bitter woman.)  No one in the family wanted this for beautiful Caroline, who had three years of college and many dreams. The problem was not simply that Peter worked endlessly and came home only to fall asleep immediately after dinner but also that his typical expression about women was, “You turn them upside down, and they’re all the same” [“a c**t”]. I heard her family try to laugh this off by saying, “Oh, Peter, that’s no way to talk!” while believing that “that’s no way to think about women!” 

Yet Caroline felt lost after four children were born close together, and she was being ignored in a huge, beautiful house (love can’t be bought with an enormous house).  She needed a warm, human relationship and a husband who paid attention to her, not one who was piling up dollars through endless work, skillfully buying land in the expanding suburbs and growing the business. Love and tenderness were what she needed, and though her widowed dad tried to provide this, it was not enough.   

However much Peter belittled women and spent little time with his kids when his wife spoke of divorce, he was rushed to the emergency room with an apparent heart attack!  There was more than one such trip to the emergency room. Although his heart felt broken emotionally, and physically, his heart was sound. Male chauvinistic denigration of women was a cover for his deep need for his long-neglected wife. 

The divorce eventually happened.  Peter accepted the loss of his trophy wife and worked with his father to take money that had been put in Caroline’s name for tax purposes into their names.  While she did nothing to protect her financial future (managing money was a man’s job, and she was consumed with guilt at ending the marriage), Caroline became enamored of the Buddhist practice of meditation, traveling to California to train as an instructor.  However, this was not enough, and she continued to feel quite guilty about the divorce. Eventually, she would drown at the age of about 46 in Long Island Sound while swimming. Perhaps she had a cramp in her leg, or she unconsciously could not tolerate the failure of her marriage and the direction of her life.   

Peter, who became a generous benefactor to a local Catholic College and mellowed with age as he struggled to maintain his health, later found a wife who was comfortable living with him.  Personally, as much as I admired him in so many ways, I can never forgive him for his sometimes crudity and for taking one of his sons to identify the body of the impressionable young man’s mother that had been floating in the Sound for over a week. While this promising young man may have inherited a fair amount of money (I know nothing of the details), I see him as having become something of a lost soul. Fortunately, his older brother made a very good life well apart from his father’s, although tragically, he died young. This example illustrates the inclination of some men to denigrate women who they so desperately need and the human costs involved.   

Misogyny is clearly an element in both elections of Donald John Trump who, as I’ve written elsewhere, in certain respects became a failed human being because of a crisis that occurred in his family when he was a two- and three-year-old. He uses other people and is incapable of real empathy, as his niece has written in her books Too Much and Never Enough: How My Family Created the World’s Most Dangerous (2020) and Who Could Ever Love You: A Family Memoir (2024). We are in an era of extraordinary change technologically and socially, which is extremely hard for most people to accept, especially when, in our flawed democratic system, there are politicians like Trump who so successfully obscure the real issues involved by using fear and wedge issues to divide rather than bring together America.  

In conclusion, the Republican Party, which I used to respect, is now about the cult of personality and spectacle rather than a group of informed citizens debating policy.  We are now living in an era where fantasy so often trumps reality. Trump is an influential entertainer turned politician who has successfully seduced not only his female and male adherents but even a larger number of Black, Hispanic, and White working and middle-class members, some of whom may even face deportation under his second presidency. The 47th President was well-known for not keeping his promises in his 45th presidency; now, I’m counting on his incompetence, inconsistency, poor choices, and love of being in the spotlight of decisions to lessen some of his impact on our struggling democracy. The roots of the misogyny that led many to vote for the Republicans have much to do with males feeling underappreciated and displaced in an era of seeking to break the glass ceiling for women, Blacks, and all minorities.  White and other women who have not sought to radically change the opportunities for their gender may also have felt pressured to do more if they voted for a woman president. There is comfort in their mostly following traditional gender patterns while watching some women advance into positions of power below the presidency, in an era when there is so much technological change and information overload.  

References:
About the Author:

Paul H. Elovitz, PhD, became a psychohistorian while teaching at Temple University and joined the Institute for Psychohistory after joining the faculty of Ramapo College in North Jersey. He has served the IPhA as president and in most of its offices and is the only colleague to have attended and presented at all annual conferences. Besides teaching psychohistory for a half century, he has published books including The Making of Psychohistory: Origins, Controversies and Pioneering Contributors (Routledge, 2018) and over 400 other publications. Dr. Elovitz is Founder and Director/Convener of the Psychohistory Forum (1982) and Founder and Editor of Clio’s Psyche (1994). He may be contacted at .

How to Cite This:

Elovitz, P.H. (2024). Free associations on the gender divide in the 2024 election with two personal illustrations. Psychohistory News, 43(4), 5.

PDF downloads:
Download this Article PDF
Download full Issue PDF



Editorial Disclaimer: The views and interpretations expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the position of Psychohistory News or the International Psychohistorical Association. For comments, please contact the author directly or submit a response to our Letters to the Editor section.
keyboard_arrow_up