Since the publication of the second English edition of Parenting for a Peaceful World in 2013, the pace of the world seems to have accelerated, upsetting our certainties and sometimes leaving us speechless before the spectacle of growing tensions, of human tragedies brought to the thresholds of our homes, arousing feelings of insecurity and vulnerability that we would no doubt have preferred to keep at bay. The war in Syria has seen an unprecedented wave of migration sweep across Europe, inspiring a resurgence of nationalism; bloody attacks have followed the creation of the Islamic State and struck at the heart of our democracies; in the United States, the presidency of Donald Trump has led to a polarization of opinion accompanied by a worrying visibility of populism around the world; the anxiety-inducing episode of Covid-19; Russia’s war against Ukraine, against a backdrop of global warming that is now perceptible, and the dramatic resurgence of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict have taken their toll on any comforting vision for the future of mankind. At first glance, then, nothing seems further from reality than Robin Grille’s proposition, taken from the final paragraph of his book: “World peace is not only a goal perfectly within our grasp, it is a modest one.”

In the face of these staggering collective challenges, Grille suggests a singular approach, one that is a priori within our grasp and likely to restore a joie de vivre that has been much battered by the prevailing gloom: let’s look after our children! By focusing on childhood and parenthood, he doesn’t distract, but plunges right to the heart of our problems. His basic premise is that the first years of life condition the rest of our lives—and who can argue with that? It follows logically that our entire societies are impacted, even forged, by these essential experiences of intimacy and sometimes secrecy. But it also follows that the violence of which we know humans to be capable has its roots in the brutalities that have been compulsively committed against the young for centuries, and then replayed collectively on the world stage. It is in this bold hypothesis, so dear to psychohistorians, that the author’s distinctive approach lies.

The book you hold in your hands brings together an impressive amount of data and sources to support such an understanding. Among these, the historical circumstances revealing the condition of children as set out in his Childhood through the Ages (Part II) can be both chilling and rejection-inducing. If you have suffered particularly adverse childhood experiences, these pages may even be too unbearable for you. Skip them without hesitation, as they are not essential to the intelligence of the whole! A little further on, Grille points out that Western countries are going through a transitional phase in terms of parenting, described as acculturative to emphasize the importance given by adults to societal expectations. This modernist approach to childhood follows centuries of mistreatment, which has not prevented mentalities from changing under the impetus of historical figures such as Rousseau, Freud and Piaget… A revolution is underway, so why be alarmed?

The author points out, however, that violence and humiliation against children are still widespread throughout the world, despite the inalienable rights they now enjoy. In our own countries, they certainly benefit from affection and greater attention, but little value is still placed on children’s feelings, and while corporal punishment is now outlawed in 65 countries, the range of methods used to perpetuate adult domination remains wide. Verbal abuse and vexation, punishments and rewards, withdrawal of attention or even isolation of a toddler deemed recalcitrant are all too often considered acceptable manipulations to force obedience. And yet, although they leave no physical traces, these marks of rejection deeply wound the child’s psyche. They end up internalizing that they are intrinsically bad and unworthy of being loved—even if their behavior has conformed to the expectations of those around them. The sense of shame resulting from repeated humiliation in childhood can lead an adult to compulsively seek approval from others, shun authentic interaction and even develop various personality disorders resulting from a loss of self-esteem.

A body of research today shows that early childhood is not only a sensitive period in the physical and psychological development of human beings, but also, and perhaps above all, a phase during which the intelligence of our emotions should flourish. Robin Grille incidentally points out that today we’re highly vulnerable to emotional manipulation – whether it’s underhand strategies by influential groups, demagogic political rhetoric or clever advertising campaigns. Addictions of all kinds are a drain on household budgets and health services, reflecting attachment deficiencies that begin in early childhood. Clearly, we still have a long way to go before our societies fully recognize children’s emotional intelligence, both within the family and in all the places that contribute to their socialization. The author convincingly demonstrates that the collective benefits of “helping” parenting practices—caring for children’s physiological and emotional needs – would far outweigh the costs of initiatives to promote such a revolution.

Robin Grille’s book is also of interest to psychotherapists and other helping professionals who are confronted with the consequences of childhood emotional deficiencies in their clientele. His Five Stages of Early Childhood Emotional Development (Part VI) provides—on recent neurological and endocrinological grounds—a veritable cartography of the emotional life of the little man during the first seven years of his life, when the most enduring traits of his character are forged. For each of these key phases, the author details the changes in the affective reality experienced by the infant, the baby and then the toddler, the most universal affective needs that must be met to ensure the child’s emotional balance, and above all the way in which his or her experience can shape his or her personality and future beliefs. If you’re on a personal therapeutic journey, you’ll find confirmation that our deepest anxieties—the fear of existing, the feeling of not being loved, the fear of being betrayed or abandoned, for example – are rooted in emotional wounds experienced in our earliest years. This recognition will enable you to position yourself more clearly in your relationships and be more attuned to the messages that signal distress in your child.

In France, since the adoption in July 2019 of the law prohibiting ordinary educational violence, authorized voices have been raised in defense of the use of traditional methods of emotional manipulation such as extinguishing infant crying or child isolation—very popular in the Anglo-Saxon world under the names of crying-out and time-out. Despite their harmful effects on the emotional balance of the youngest children, these practices are receiving unexpected media support, reflecting the public’s dismay at the inevitable change in our educational practices. With innumerable sources giving her book an undeniable scientific basis, Robin Grille can offer new perspectives to parents who wonder about their children’s well-being, and a corpus of reference for those among the political decision-makers who are working for a more peaceful society.

About the Author:

Marc-André Cotton is a psychohistorian and editor of Regard conscient, a research project founded in 2002 that examines the consequences of violence in everyday child-rearing, building on the work of Alice Miller and Sylvie Vermeulen. He is the author of a book exploring the consequences of “poisonous pedagogy” during the presidency of George W. Bush and currently serves as president of the International Psychohistorical Association (IPhA).

How to Cite This:

Cotton, M-A. (2024). Parents for peace: Educational project for a world without violence. Preface to the French edition of the book by Robin Grille, Psychohistory News, 43(3), 5.



Editorial Disclaimer: The views and interpretations expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the position of Psychohistory News or the International Psychohistorical Association. For comments, please contact the author directly or submit a response to our Letters to the Editor section.
keyboard_arrow_up